Dominic Deegan Fansite

Joined : 19 Sep 2007 Posts : 31

I've been a big fan of the DD webcomic for awhile now...But I have to say, everyone here is so critical of Mookie's works. Insulting his art, his storylines, whining about too much this, or not enough that.

If you want to be so critical, YOU try doing a webcomic that goes on this long, and YOU try to keep a huge storyline intact throughout it.

Sure, Dominic is a bit self-centered, but it would be hard not to be if you could see the future. If you could manipulate people like that, without even trying that hard, would you?

Saying stuff like "Too much drama!" and being overly critical of Mookie's work seems to be...well, unfair. I mean, he works hard on this webcomic, having to balance it between his real life, and you people. For ONCE, I'd like to see someone PRAISING what Mookie does. He's a better writer than I am, and a FAR better artist. Just my two cents.

Where's the love, man? D:

Subject: Re: Where's the love? Thu Sep 27, 2007 11:08 am

Is that a challenge?

Edit: I ask merely because if one isn't allowed to criticize a comic because the person hasn't made one, does that mean praising it also requires the effort in making one too?

Just because I don't shoot movies, does that mean I shouldn't say bad things about Lindsay Lohan movies?

Subject: Re: Where's the love? Thu Sep 27, 2007 11:37 am

>->O Joined : 21 Jul 2007 Posts : 233

Left the forum Joined : 30 Apr 2007 Posts : 732

Central: Actually, if you watch, you'll see that some of us do offer praise at different points. I will usually praise virtually any appearance of Spark, and I'm quite fond of even the worst puns, for instance.

Most of us have something we like, and will comment on that. The big problem is that Mookie has a handful of issues that, for whatever reason, never seem to get addressed. 2-3 years ago, they were usually minor annoyances, like a grain of sand caught in your swimsuit.

Now imagine having that grain of sand stuck there for 2-3 years, and you'll see where some of the animosity comes from. If the current strip hits on a particular person's pet peeve, that person becomes a lot more likely to make a negative comment.

That said, there are a handful of folks who, for some reason, seem to think Mookie is the antithesis of all that should be done in webcomicry. These folks, I don't get, and generally just ignore them. If anything, they actually make it more likely that Mookie will simply discount all criticism, valid and otherwise, simply because it seems like he couldn't win, anyway.

Subject: Re: Where's the love? Thu Sep 27, 2007 8:58 pm

Oh god, this again? Why does EVERY new person have to start this argument ;_;
_________________
"Bears have penises. They can stick it in butts."
~LS

Subject: Re: Where's the love? Thu Sep 27, 2007 8:59 pm

They expect a 'fansite' to be full of praise?
_________________
You're about to die. Scream if you must.

Subject: Re: Where's the love? Thu Sep 27, 2007 9:01 pm

Honestly, where's the hate?

I haven't seen any venom attached to the comic. Some criticisms here and there, and a lot of sarcasm. o_O?
_________________

Subject: Re: Where's the love? Thu Sep 27, 2007 9:10 pm

Because the only valid form of fan commentary is blind praise

_________________
Rules of the Culture of Nice
[list][*]First Law: A person may not criticize a webcomic, or, through inaction, allow a webcomic to be criticized.
[*]Second Law: A person must only say things that are pleasing to webcomic creators except where such things would conflict with the First Law.
[*]Third Law: A webcomic creator must protect his or her creation from criticism as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law.[/list:u]

Subject: Re: Where's the love? Thu Sep 27, 2007 9:12 pm

To be completely honest, Central, the mere fact that I bother to critique and criticize Mookie's work is evidence that I am a DD fan. If I didn't like it, I wouldn't bother to critique his work or to tell him what I think he's done badly - I simply would stop reading his comic and stop attending his forums.
_________________
Boris: "Oh I love it! UNKNOWN MAGIC! Let's go stick our heads in it, guys! OH COME ON!!."

Spoiler:
	HM #32, #34

Joined : 19 Sep 2007 Posts : 31

Well, I didn't expect blind praise, and you don't have to be so venomous about it. I just didn't expect people to be SO critical. I mean, I expected some, but I see more than I expected.

And to Java/Schtolty:
How can Dominic miscalculate something if he KNOWS the outcome? If you KNOW what you need to do, and you KNOW what will happen when you do it, where's the risk? If its an absolute A+B=C, then, no risk. Of course, he probably is a bit too sure of himself.

>->O Joined : 21 Jul 2007 Posts : 233

Because people with second-sight-shields don't exist.

Because Dominic never actually misinterpreted things that lead to the deaths of certain blue-skinned people.

Because The Grey isn't actually beyond the scope of seers to predict the outcome.

Sorry, but second sight =/= omniscience.

Subject: Re: Where's the love? Thu Sep 27, 2007 9:49 pm

Misinterpretation of divinations is half the fun of reading stories about seers.
_________________
Boris: "Oh I love it! UNKNOWN MAGIC! Let's go stick our heads in it, guys! OH COME ON!!."

Spoiler:
	HM #32, #34

Subject: Re: Where's the love? Thu Sep 27, 2007 9:51 pm

I'd say closer to 82% of the fun.

A good 2% at LEAST is justified rape.

10% is strip slays

The rest is "misc"
_________________
"Bears have penises. They can stick it in butts."
~LS

Honor and Virtue Joined : 31 Mar 2007 Posts : 4233

Slays are only 10%? That's less than taxes!